Banquo wrote:can there ever have been a bigger likely reversal of fortunes from having Oz 122-8 to losing by say 250 runs? Oz were also minus 16 for 3 at one point.
Buttler's place can no longer be sacrosanct, and he's no test 5.
Agreed, no specialist batsman in that team bar Root should feel comfortable *.But he is a better keeper and batsman than YJB. He has averaged 37 since his return to test cricket, which is far from perfect, but a full 10 runs more than YJB has averaged since Root took over (13.77 since turn of the year).
The selectors have got themselves in a right pickle.
*Stokes as an all rounder is probably ok.