Why would the Chicago result be more indicative than the Dublin result?Scrumhead wrote:The other RC sides are pretty much in the doldrums so the Ireland result in Chicago and the Lions tour are a much better barometer of how good this All Black side is.
Can we now stop fetishising the All Blacks?
Moderator: Puja
-
- Posts: 938
- Joined: Tue Feb 09, 2016 8:11 pm
Re: Can we now stop fetishising the All Blacks?
TBH we don't have the greatest coaching team. It's not bad, but it's certainly not in a patch on Henry's setup, and it'll get weaker when Smith retires after the RC. But that should be rectified when Cotter and Schmidt take over in 2020.
-
- Posts: 13436
- Joined: Fri Feb 12, 2016 11:17 am
Re: Can we now stop fetishising the All Blacks?
Retallick and Co were on the up in the 2nd half today once Smith decided to go back to test 1 basics, i.e. ignore BB who was being more wasteful than Farrell going left to right, and send the forwards tacking off 9. Luckily for the Lions Smith was promptly subbed off by Hansen to save Smith for the big games coming upSpiffy wrote:Brodie is a hell of player and an icon for the ABs. Perhaps their most important key player. If you succeed in keeping him relatively quiet, you go a long way to giving the ABs a competitive game and nudging ahead in the mind game stakes. The Lions pack, especially Itoje, did a grand job in this respect of policing him in the last two tests.Digby wrote:The prime of BrodieMellsblue wrote:It'll be difficult to not unless Retallick stops slapping his thighs during the pre-match dance. Watching a man that handsome doing something that erotic makes me question my sexuality.
A drawn series is a little disappointing for both sides but a pretty fair outcome.
- Puja
- Posts: 17528
- Joined: Tue Feb 09, 2016 9:16 pm
Re: Can we now stop fetishising the All Blacks?
I would've said the Dublin result was also fairly indicative. You won it, but you were far from dominant. You're human, like the rest of us.zer0 wrote:TBH we don't have the greatest coaching team. It's not bad, but it's certainly not in a patch on Henry's setup, and it'll get weaker when Smith retires after the RC. But that should be rectified when Cotter and Schmidt take over in 2020.
Why would the Chicago result be more indicative than the Dublin result?Scrumhead wrote:The other RC sides are pretty much in the doldrums so the Ireland result in Chicago and the Lions tour are a much better barometer of how good this All Black side is.
Puja
Backist Monk
- morepork
- Posts: 7520
- Joined: Wed Feb 10, 2016 1:50 pm
Re: Can we now stop fetishising the All Blacks?
Again, I'm struggling to see this as a revelation. If you have an issue with your media pundits engaging in a bit of remedial hyperbole re the ABs, then write a strongly worded letter to the editor.
- Puja
- Posts: 17528
- Joined: Tue Feb 09, 2016 9:16 pm
Re: Can we now stop fetishising the All Blacks?
Not the media - people on here!morepork wrote:Again, I'm struggling to see this as a revelation. If you have an issue with your media pundits engaging in a bit of remedial hyperbole re the ABs, then write a strongly worded letter to the editor.
Mind, speaking of media hyperbole, the NZ Herald is setting a new record for it in declaring that Hansen has lost control of the All Blacks and that "things must change" before the RWC. It's a fairly impressive meltdown.
Puja
Backist Monk
- skidger
- Posts: 213
- Joined: Thu Feb 11, 2016 9:09 am
Re: Can we now stop fetishising the All Blacks?
In fairness when you look at who that article is written by you can instantly brush it off.Puja wrote:Not the media - people on here!morepork wrote:Again, I'm struggling to see this as a revelation. If you have an issue with your media pundits engaging in a bit of remedial hyperbole re the ABs, then write a strongly worded letter to the editor.
Mind, speaking of media hyperbole, the NZ Herald is setting a new record for it in declaring that Hansen has lost control of the All Blacks and that "things must change" before the RWC. It's a fairly impressive meltdown.
Puja
-
- Posts: 13436
- Joined: Fri Feb 12, 2016 11:17 am
Re: Can we now stop fetishising the All Blacks?
Suggests it's a Rattue article, those seemed based on several tins of Alphabetti Spaghetti, a lot a laxative, and the NZ Herald publishing whatever comes outskidger wrote:In fairness when you look at who that article is written by you can instantly brush it off.Puja wrote:Not the media - people on here!morepork wrote:Again, I'm struggling to see this as a revelation. If you have an issue with your media pundits engaging in a bit of remedial hyperbole re the ABs, then write a strongly worded letter to the editor.
Mind, speaking of media hyperbole, the NZ Herald is setting a new record for it in declaring that Hansen has lost control of the All Blacks and that "things must change" before the RWC. It's a fairly impressive meltdown.
Puja
- skidger
- Posts: 213
- Joined: Thu Feb 11, 2016 9:09 am
Re: Can we now stop fetishising the All Blacks?
It is. Like a southern hemisphere mash up of Stephen Jones,Beefeater,Stuart Barnes and a twist of Scott Quinnell.Digby wrote:Suggests it's a Rattue article, those seemed based on several tins of Alphabetti Spaghetti, a lot a laxative, and the NZ Herald publishing whatever comes outskidger wrote:In fairness when you look at who that article is written by you can instantly brush it off.Puja wrote:
Not the media - people on here!
Mind, speaking of media hyperbole, the NZ Herald is setting a new record for it in declaring that Hansen has lost control of the All Blacks and that "things must change" before the RWC. It's a fairly impressive meltdown.
Puja
- Which Tyler
- Posts: 9067
- Joined: Tue Feb 09, 2016 8:43 pm
- Location: Tewkesbury
- Contact:
Re: Can we now stop fetishising the All Blacks?
Which means that he's still an upgrade on Gregor Paul, who is to rugby what the Daily Mail is to Medical Researchskidger wrote:It is. Like a southern hemisphere mash up of Stephen Jones,Beefeater,Stuart Barnes and a twist of Scott Quinnell.Digby wrote:Suggests it's a Rattue article, those seemed based on several tins of Alphabetti Spaghetti, a lot a laxative, and the NZ Herald publishing whatever comes outskidger wrote:
In fairness when you look at who that article is written by you can instantly brush it off.
- Oakboy
- Posts: 6308
- Joined: Wed Feb 10, 2016 9:42 am
Re: Can we now stop fetishising the All Blacks?
Bloody hell, poor old Beef has had some stick on here but bracketing him with those three fools is OTT.skidger wrote:It is. Like a southern hemisphere mash up of Stephen Jones,Beefeater,Stuart Barnes and a twist of Scott Quinnell.Digby wrote:Suggests it's a Rattue article, those seemed based on several tins of Alphabetti Spaghetti, a lot a laxative, and the NZ Herald publishing whatever comes outskidger wrote:
In fairness when you look at who that article is written by you can instantly brush it off.
-
- Posts: 5939
- Joined: Sun Jul 03, 2016 10:33 am
Re: Can we now stop fetishising the All Blacks?
My point was that the Lions tour and Chicago demonstrated that the All Blacks are beatable. Puja is correct too - the return game in Dublin was a hard fought contest that suggests that the best of the NH (specifically Ireland and England) are better equipped to beat the All Blacks than the RC sides are right now.Puja wrote:I would've said the Dublin result was also fairly indicative. You won it, but you were far from dominant. You're human, like the rest of us.zer0 wrote:TBH we don't have the greatest coaching team. It's not bad, but it's certainly not in a patch on Henry's setup, and it'll get weaker when Smith retires after the RC. But that should be rectified when Cotter and Schmidt take over in 2020.
Why would the Chicago result be more indicative than the Dublin result?Scrumhead wrote:The other RC sides are pretty much in the doldrums so the Ireland result in Chicago and the Lions tour are a much better barometer of how good this All Black side is.
Puja
- skidger
- Posts: 213
- Joined: Thu Feb 11, 2016 9:09 am
Re: Can we now stop fetishising the All Blacks?
Liked to wum,talk nonsense and obsessed with big men. I think its reasonable.Oakboy wrote:Bloody hell, poor old Beef has had some stick on here but bracketing him with those three fools is OTT.skidger wrote:It is. Like a southern hemisphere mash up of Stephen Jones,Beefeater,Stuart Barnes and a twist of Scott Quinnell.Digby wrote:
Suggests it's a Rattue article, those seemed based on several tins of Alphabetti Spaghetti, a lot a laxative, and the NZ Herald publishing whatever comes out
- oldbackrow
- Posts: 281
- Joined: Tue Feb 09, 2016 8:46 pm
- Location: Darkest Rotherham
- Contact:
Re: Can we now stop fetishising the All Blacks?
Shes never posted on here, as far as I know, but you seem to be describing my wife!skidger wrote: Liked to wum,talk nonsense and obsessed with big men. I think its reasonable.

- morepork
- Posts: 7520
- Joined: Wed Feb 10, 2016 1:50 pm
Re: Can we now stop fetishising the All Blacks?
Puja wrote:Not the media - people on here!morepork wrote:Again, I'm struggling to see this as a revelation. If you have an issue with your media pundits engaging in a bit of remedial hyperbole re the ABs, then write a strongly worded letter to the editor.
Mind, speaking of media hyperbole, the NZ Herald is setting a new record for it in declaring that Hansen has lost control of the All Blacks and that "things must change" before the RWC. It's a fairly impressive meltdown.
Puja
Rattue has to make his infrequent mewlings count so he tends to go overboard with that rag of a periodical whenever it gives him the chance.
-
- Posts: 263
- Joined: Fri Feb 12, 2016 5:12 pm
Re: Can we now stop fetishising the All Blacks?
Got sky for the tests, and thought cool I'll watch Super Rugby. Do you all remember when Super Rugby was this amazing thing far beyond us plodding Northern hemisphere people?Timbo wrote:In the last 18 months England have averaged 35 points and 3.4 try's per game against rugby championship opposition. If the shoe fits...morepork wrote:Timbo wrote:
Quite a lot of handling errors from them all series...and a huge number from their Super teams in the warm up games. Suspect they've spent a bit too much time in recent seasons playing against flimsy second rate defences, making that aspect of their game look a bit better than it actually is.
Meeeaow!
Well I watched Brumbies V reds and Stormers v Sunwolves. They were all rubbish. Don't know what has happened to Quade Cooper either. He looks like he's been drugged.. It can't be helping NZ teams if that's the standard they are facing.
- morepork
- Posts: 7520
- Joined: Wed Feb 10, 2016 1:50 pm
Re: Can we now stop fetishising the All Blacks?
Are you after a cuddle? There are some bitter mofos on here. You did well. Enjoy it.
-
- Posts: 448
- Joined: Tue Feb 09, 2016 7:09 pm
Re: Can we now stop fetishising the All Blacks?
You are only now realising that this board is mostly made up of the bitter?morepork wrote:Are you after a cuddle? There are some bitter mofos on here. You did well. Enjoy it.
Anyway, we merely have to say we're fetishing the 2011-15 All Blacks, problem solved. Much like Dairy Milk, the new recipe has some things to improve on.
- Mr Mwenda
- Posts: 2456
- Joined: Wed Feb 10, 2016 7:42 am
Re: Can we now stop fetishising the All Blacks?
Cuddles always welcome, mind.
- skidger
- Posts: 213
- Joined: Thu Feb 11, 2016 9:09 am
Re: Can we now stop fetishising the All Blacks?
Yes that sums it up. How can you lose McCaw,Carter,Nonu and Smith and not look a little more beatable.Peat wrote:You are only now realising that this board is mostly made up of the bitter?morepork wrote:Are you after a cuddle? There are some bitter mofos on here. You did well. Enjoy it.
Anyway, we merely have to say we're fetishing the 2011-15 All Blacks, problem solved. Much like Dairy Milk, the new recipe has some things to improve on.
- skidger
- Posts: 213
- Joined: Thu Feb 11, 2016 9:09 am
Re: Can we now stop fetishising the All Blacks?
It will be the same when Tom Wood and Haskell hang up their England boots. We won't look so superhuman.
-
- Posts: 12040
- Joined: Sat Feb 13, 2016 5:10 pm
Re: Can we now stop fetishising the All Blacks?
You seem oddly defensive about all this.morepork wrote:Are you after a cuddle? There are some bitter mofos on here. You did well. Enjoy it.
I certainly get what Poo-jar is saying to some extent, I'm very surprised the Lions got as close as they did, yet there was a whole lot room for improvement. Though the ABs could say the same.
- morepork
- Posts: 7520
- Joined: Wed Feb 10, 2016 1:50 pm
Re: Can we now stop fetishising the All Blacks?
Mikey Brown wrote:You seem oddly defensive about all this.morepork wrote:Are you after a cuddle? There are some bitter mofos on here. You did well. Enjoy it.
I certainly get what Poo-jar is saying to some extent, I'm very surprised the Lions got as close as they did, yet there was a whole lot room for improvement. Though the ABs could say the same.
That's a flimsy second rate critique.
I suppose I can't help chiming in. The points raised are valid, I'll admit.
-
- Posts: 12040
- Joined: Sat Feb 13, 2016 5:10 pm
Re: Can we now stop fetishising the All Blacks?
What's second rate about it? I am surprised. There was vast room for improvement from both teams. I barely watched any of it because it didn't really grab me, so can't offer much more detail. But is anyone bitter about it? I may well have missed that too.